Posted in Podcast
Can Pilates, yoga or TRX build enough strength for trail running?
Episode 400
14 Minutes – Oct 5, 2026
Chapters
Questions this episode answers
- Is reformer Pilates enough strength training for runners?
- At first, yes, and I like that you can add resistance on a reformer. Once you can do more than about 30 reps without getting close to failure, it's no longer enough and you need to add weight.
- Does yoga build leg strength for running?
- For a beginner, yes. Warrior poses and getting up and down from chaturangas train a big range of motion with body weight. At some point you will top out.
- Is a TRX squat better than an air squat?
- Not really. It's basically the same as an air squat or body weight lunge, and you can push with your arms. Its value is letting you get deeper than you could without support.
- How many reps in reserve should I leave?
- Right now we aim for around 2 to 3 reps in reserve on sets of 5 to 30 reps. Stopping with 5 or more left in the tank is close to a waste of time.
- Why did my strength go up so fast when I started lifting?
- Those are beginner gains. In roughly the first six months, most of the jump comes from your nervous system recruiting the muscle you already have, not new muscle.
Do Pilates, yoga or TRX count as strength training?
Short answer: yes and no.
Usually yes, at first. If you do no resistance training at all, literally anything helps. So yes, you can use a TRX, a reformer Pilates class or yoga to start building leg strength for running.
I'm not bashing any of these. They are helpful. Just take them for what they are.
What each one does well
The big benefit is range of motion. These classes use your muscles through a large range you're probably not used to. Think about the warrior poses in yoga, or getting on and off the floor from your chaturangas. That's a big range, it's body weight, and you do it a lot in a class.
A TRX (a strap system anchored to a wall) lets you go deeper because the straps support your balance. Then you can move to single leg work, which doubles the load on that leg. Don't be fooled, though. A strap squat is basically an air squat. A strap lunge is basically a body weight lunge. If anything it's less resistance, because you can push with your arms.
Where straps shine is for someone who can't physically get down. Dr. Dawne Costantino showed this in a recent video, using the straps to help people with hip impingement get through a big range by letting them tilt the pelvis back. People commented that they hadn't been that low in years. That exposure to range can be very helpful.
Usually we want a large range of motion when we do resistance training. If you're not strong enough to get there yet, use that range first. Build strength in it. Then add external weight.
Reformer Pilates has one thing I really like. You can add resistance. Adding resistance is the crux of building strength and moving the needle.
Beginner gains and why you top out
In roughly the first six months of training, your numbers jump. Your weight or your reps climb fast. That's mostly not new muscle. It's your nervous system linking up to recruit the muscle you already have.
So if you went from body weight squats to 50 pounds in three weeks, that's a newbie gain. Nobody who has lifted for a while jumps 50 pounds. Progress comes in smaller steps. That's normal.
This is why yoga, TRX and Pilates work early. But you may top out pretty quickly. When you do, you add weight. That's when you get to the gym, with machines, hand weights and barbells.
Reps in reserve: when the work starts to count
The current guidelines I follow put useful sets somewhere between 5 and 30 reps. You should finish without much gas left in the tank. The term is reps in reserve: how many reps you had left before complete failure.
Right now we aim for around 2 to 3 in reserve. Stopping with 5 or more left is close to a waste of time. The earlier reps just lead up to the ones that make the physical change.
I don't have people go to failure often anymore. Form tends to break down near failure. With novices and heavier weights, that raises the risk of injury.
If you hit failure around 30 reps on a reformer, that still counts. If you're doing 40, 50 or more, the load isn't enough to make a good change in an efficient amount of time. I think 100 reps to failure would still do something. But who has time for that? Adding weight gets you there faster.
Lift like James Bond and match the energy system
I meet a lot of people who had a bad experience lifting and decided it's not safe. They stick to light hand weights or body weight for the legs. In my experience, gym injuries usually come from competing or expecting gains in a single day.
Lift like James Bond. Live to die another day. Leave a little gas in the tank. Most of your lifting should be less intense than you think. Still hard, but not maxing out five days straight. The goal is to do this for a very long time.
I put yoga, Pilates and TRX in an "other" category. They're a different modality. Just like only strength training won't make you the best runner, these won't replace lifting.
Think about which energy system you're training. Running is aerobic. Weight training should be shorter efforts, anaerobic. Hour-long HIIT classes where you never stop are great hard work, but they aren't really resistance training. You need to recover between sets so you can push a challenging weight again.
Key takeaways
- If you do no strength work, Pilates, yoga or TRX is a real step forward.
- Their main value is training through a large range of motion with body weight.
- Early progress is mostly your nervous system, and you will top out on body weight.
- Aim to finish sets of 5 to 30 reps with about 2 to 3 reps in reserve.
- When classes stop challenging you inside that range, add external weight.
- Leave gas in the tank, rest between sets, and train for the long haul.
At a glance
- Conditions and injuries
- Running-related knee conditions
- Hip impingement
- Deconditioning in runners
- Anatomy involved
- Leg musculature
- Pelvis
- Nervous system recruitment
- Symptoms described
- Limited squat depth
- Plateau in strength gains
- Fear of lifting after a bad experience
- Treatments and exercises
- Reformer Pilates
- Yoga
- TRX strap training
- Progressive weight training
- Reps in reserve guidance
Episode Transcript
This transcript was generated automatically (whisper.cpp large-v3-turbo) and may contain errors.
Hey everyone, this is your co-host Sebastian with the Restoring Human Movement Podcast. Thanks for joining the show today. In the last few episodes, we've covered some aspects of strength training or resistance training with our running population that we see here at Performance Plays. And the first one I covered a little bit more of just like general philosophy of like why resistance training can be helpful for, it can change gait, it can change the physical abilities and the tolerances of the person and their joints, like their knees and so on. So there was a lot of overlay in the first episode.
The second one was based upon how things like hip dominant exercises like deadlifting can be helpful for runners with knee conditions. I didn't even cover like how helpful it can be for backs and ankles and heel issues, etc. But it can be helpful for all those things. And the knee dominant ones, the knee dominant exercises or quad dominant ones for somebody with a knee condition, or at least figuring out how that can help break the cycle of a reoccurrence of a knee condition as well. Today, I'm going to cover just some of the questions that we've gotten about, is this X as a good enough for resistance training?
And one of the ones I've gotten recently was about Pilates. I'm not bashing Pilates at all. I actually got a similar question about a TRX, which is a strap system that people put up on a wall, which we do have at our office here. We don't have anything like Pilates, but I've had people go into Pilates as a suggestion as well. And also, I've gotten the question about yoga too. Like, I'm going to go, is it enough to go to those things like use a TRX, go to Pilates or to yoga to build strength in the legs to check the box of strength training and resistance training for our running population? And the short answer is yes and no.
Usually, yes. Again, if you've been listening to the series so far, the overlying theme with people who are not doing any resistance training, doing literally anything is helpful. So can you use a TRX or a Pilates? In this case, I'm thinking of a reformer. Or can you do yoga? Yeah, you can do all of those. And the benefit is that they start to use the musculature in a large range of motion that they're really not accustomed to. I mean, think about the things in yoga, for example, like the warrior poses, getting on and off the floor from your chaturangas. Like, that's a big range of motion, and it is body weight.
So, and how many times do you do that in a class? A lot. And I know there's a lot of different types of yoga too, by the way. So, but this is the, what is it, the power one that I'm thinking of that people do. I remember talking to someone who was a yoga instructor. And so we discussed it for a while. And they said, you know, actually, the only thing that really matters is the sabhasana at the end, the sleepy time. And I said, really? I said, what's all the other stuff? And they said, oh, it's just stuff to get you to the sleepy time. And so, but I feel like most people do it because they want the physical activity from it.
And, but for a, for a beginner, yes, doing yoga is helpful for strength training, but at some point you will top out in it. Now, I'll go into TRX now or some of the strap systems. Is that good enough? Yes, the beginning it is because you're going through a larger range of motion because of usually a balance aspect than you would if you didn't have the strap support. And then you can go to a single leg aspect, which is body weight. So you're getting to the point where you double the weight on a single leg, but you can go through a larger range of motion than you could if you didn't have the support system.
Now, is it the same as doing air squats? Yes, it's kind of the same. Is it the same as doing step back lunges or body weight lunges? Yes, it's the same thing. So don't be fooled that just because there's a strap there that it's going to do anything. In fact, it'd probably be less resistance training because you shoot with your arms. But for someone who cannot physically get down, like we did a YouTube video recently where Dawne Costantino had showed using the straps to go through a great range of motion to help out with conditions like hip impingement because it allows people to posteriorly tilt their pelvis.
I mean, the comments that we've gotten on that short video, people say, I haven't been able to get that low in two years and decades, et cetera. I've never been able to get that low. So being able to do that, expose yourself to the range of motion can be very helpful. And usually a large range of motion is what we want if we're going to do some resistance training, unless for some reason the lift or the person's mobility doesn't allow for it. But if they're just not strong enough to go through that range, then why don't we use that range first, build some strength in it, and then start to add external weights, which is going to be our resistance, like with machines and hand weights, barbells, et cetera.
Now, on to Pilates, we're former Pilates. Now, I've only done it a couple of times, but what I like is that you can add resistance. So adding resistance is kind of like the crux of building some strength and moving the needle. You will always get stronger. At some point, it'll be harder to get stronger because you don't have what we call the beginner's gains. In the beginning, I think they say for about like the first six months, you'll get an enormous amount of increase in your resistance or your weight or your reps will go way up with the same amount of weight. And the reason for this is not because you're building muscle, really.
It's because you're linking all of the nervous system up better to recruit the muscle that you already have. So whenever you hear somebody saying, well, I was squatting in the beginning like three weeks ago. I was doing just my body weight and now I'm up to 50 pounds in my hands. That's a newbie game. Like nobody jumps 50 pounds in a lift when they've been around lifting for a while. Like you go up in much smaller increments, which is not a bad thing, but just kind of know that that does happen very commonly. And that's why something like Pilates or Reformer Pilates is fine. But at some point you may tap out pretty quickly.
So what do you do when you start to tap out? And we add weight. You got to add resistance. And this is where you start getting to the gym with the machines and so on. And this is where the answer of, or my answer of, does Reformer Pilates and yoga and TRX lower body workout, do they count for resistance training? Well, in this case, they don't. Because you're going beyond the amount of the general recommended rep range in still having gas in the tank. If you guys listen to some of the podcasts that I'd suggested from Strength Changes Everything, they go over some of the guidelines associated to resistance training.
And like we kind of say that like between 5 and 30 reps, at least at this point in time, I'm sure they'll change their mind at some point, that you should kind of get to the point where you don't really have a lot of gas in the tank. They call it, the term is what they call it is reps in reserve, reps that you have left before complete failure. I think it's right now we're saying around 2 to 3, but in the past, they say that basically anything that is like above 5 reps in reserve, so say you have 10 left and you stop, but you could have done 10, is kind of like almost like a waste of time. Like all the other reps are just leading to the point where you really make the physical change, which is going to be 5 reps in reserve all the way down to like 1 or even to failure.
Now, I don't really have people go to failure too often anymore, mainly because of I think the form breakdown happens more often into those higher reps where the fatigue point is there, the failure rate is there. And especially with novice, like you'll have a greater potential of injury if you start breaking form, especially with a higher weight. Now, if you're going to complete failure around the 30 rep mark, the weight's pretty low, the weight is very low in comparison to what you can actually do. So, like at that point, yeah, you can go to Reformers Pilates and do like 30 reps to the point of failure and yeah, that still counts, right?
But if you start going above 30, 40, 50, it's like, yeah, these aren't hard enough. The weight's not significant enough to really make a good change, at least in an efficient amount of time. Personally, I believe that there will be a change. Even if you go to 100 reps, like you get to a point of failure, it'll still do a significant change at some point. But who has the time to do 100 reps for the last five to really make a difference? So, adding the weight there helps to stimulate a little bit faster so you don't have to burn all your time in the gym doing like 3,000 reps of something just to get a little bit of a burn.
I've met a lot of people who have had a bad experience with resistance training over the years. Unfortunately, some of them made up their mind that I'm not going to do that anymore or they're not going to do anything really significantly hard. I don't challenge myself anymore. They'll do hand weights, you know, to the point kind of where they're bored. Or they'll do just body weight stuff in the lower body or then they'll do upper body like significant challenges. So, it's almost like they've built distrust in certain parts of their body and given themselves kind of like the mental narrative of like it's not safe to do that.
Now, my personal experience with people having injuries at the gym are usually revolving around more of a competition aspect or not realizing that the gains don't happen in a single day. And that you should almost lift like James Bond would. You live to die another day. Like, you leave a little bit of gas in the tank. You don't have to go hard all the time. In fact, I think a lot of the lifting that people should be doing is probably less intensive than you really think. Like, it's still going to be hard, but it's not like, man, I pushed the hardest weight that I possibly could the last five days just because I know, like, blowing everything out of the water is going to help me.
And that's not really helpful in the long term either. Like, really, the goal is to do something for a very long time. I love to hear some older individuals, like, when they retire, they go to the gym five days a week and you watch them. It's like, they're doing stuff and they're mixing it up and they're just like, it's kind of like their third place. I love that. And I think that's a great way to go. And I know our runners that we see don't have time for that because they're spending their time in their mileage, but still make the few days that you have efficient. And as you get more mature in the gym, you're going to want to make sure that you optimize some of your lifts.
Now, I hope I've answered the question about Pilates and yoga and stuff like that. Not to say, remember, I'm not, I don't want to bash these things. They are, they are helpful, but only to a certain point. I think everyone needs to kind of take them for what they are. They're just a different modality. I put them into an other category. Just like if I was to say, I'm going to make the best runner than I can and only do strength training. That's not really realistic either. It's just, it's just a different type of exercise and a different type of energy system. One of my friends did a great presentation at our office years ago where he talked about like more so considering the lifts or the exercises that you're doing and breaking them down into what energy system that you are trying to stimulate.
With cardiovascular fitness, you're doing aerobic. Like, I think we all know what aerobic fitness is by now at this point. But then with weight training, the effort shouldn't be so long to where you get into an aerobic phase. So, it should be shorter lived. Like, you're training anaerobic. It's just a different energy system, which I won't really get out into today. But I think that's a really clean way of looking at it. Just like with HIITS training and group classes that last an hour and you're moving the whole time. Like, I love that people are doing hard stuff and I die in those classes when I'm gone.
But if you don't really have time to recover and you're always up and up and up, that's not really a lot of resistance training either. Like, you can't physically recover. You need to make sure that you recover between your sets to actually push a challenging amount of weight again. You can't just be over and over and over with minimal break. That's just something else. Okay. I hope this was helpful to everybody and you're starting to learn things through these podcasts. Remember, if you want to ever see us in person or do a telehealth with us, we do have virtual services. Our number is 714-502-4243.
And we also have, we try to take some of the questions, ask them on our email, info at p2sportscare.com. I'm going to continue down this thought process for a while. I'm really hyped on strength training at this moment. And I can't say that I always have been. I used to really like it. And then I kind of lost a passion for it because I got busy in life and I found my way back into it. And I, I really love being at the gym and, but I don't like going, I love being there, but I don't like going. And I think at least for me in the, in the future, I want to make sure that I hopefully dedicate times in the day or in the week that are not constricted.
Like I don't have to rush off and do something immediately after the gym. I go in the morning right now on some days. And I feel like if I don't wake up early enough that I'm rushed in getting the things done that I want to do. And I don't really feel like I'm enjoying it. Now, the days where I'd been, I got off work early sometimes. And right now it here, it's like three 50. I can go to the gym right now and I don't really need to make dinner for a little bit of time. I got a couple hours and it's really not a hard stop, right? I could just mess around there and keep finding the buffet that I mentioned earlier for a while.
And I really liked that less press time. I like the break and it shouldn't feel like cardio when I'm doing it. All right, guys, if you have more questions, reach out to us in the email. We'd love to answer them in the podcast form if we can. And we'd love to see you and help you with telehealth or in person if we can. Take care.
