Posted in Podcast
Why a Hamstring Injury Comes Back After Months Without Pain
Episode 1
16 Minutes – Sep 28, 2016
Chapters
Questions this episode answers
- Why did my hamstring pain come back after months of no pain?
- Often the rehab matched one activity but not another. Sprinting and kicking load the hamstring differently, and kicking adds more range, different force and rotation. Skipped warm-ups, no cool-down or a larger partial tear can also play a part.
- How long does a hamstring injury take to fully heal?
- Longer than it feels. Tissue keeps remodeling for up to a year, and I've heard sources say two years. Six months pain-free doesn't mean the tissue is finished changing.
- Are eccentric exercises good for a hamstring strain?
- There's a lot of research showing eccentric loading helps hamstring injuries, and I think it's useful. But it treats the hamstring as if it works alone between the knee and hip. You also need to look at the trunk, hips, arm swing and foot contact.
- Do my core and hips affect hamstring injuries?
- Yes. A lot of current thinking says hamstring problems often start with how the trunk and hips stabilize. If they don't do their job, the hamstrings work excessively when you run and kick.
- What should hamstring rehab include for soccer or football?
- Rehab should match your goals. If you sprint, we practice sprint-like motions in a controlled setting. If you kick, we also train the larger range and rotation, plus complex lifts, rotational work and lateral movement.
A hamstring that came back after six months
A reader left me a long comment on one of my YouTube videos about hamstring stretching. I've cleaned it up slightly.
He had hamstring problems for about a year and had to stop playing football. He saw a physio. Things went well. He ran and sprinted for months with no pain. Then he kicked a ball for 20 minutes, and the pain came back the next day.
Six months pain-free. Working hard to do everything right. Then it's back. He was very down about it.
I get it. I've had two hamstring injuries myself. Each one put me down for a while. Right when one improved and I forgot about it, the other one became a problem. That's why I take researching hamstrings personally.
Rehab has to match your goal
He sprinted. He didn't kick. That difference matters.
I think rehab should be built around the goals of the athlete. If your goal is sprinting, we should have you doing motions similar to sprinting in a controlled setting. We keep the hamstring, trunk, hips and your contact with the ground all in mind.
Kicking is different. It uses a larger range of motion and puts a different type of force on the muscle. It's also slightly rotational. Your plant leg spins and swivels on the ground. So that may need its own rehab, done a little differently.
Other questions I'd ask:
- Did you warm up, or just start kicking with friends?
- Did you cool down?
- Was there a larger partial tear nobody knew about, one that was ready for sprinting but not for kicking?
Why the trunk and hips matter for hamstrings
A lot of current thinking says hamstring problems often start in the trunk and hips. Are they doing their job, so the hamstrings don't have to work excessively when you kick and run?
There's a lot of research showing eccentric loading helps hamstring injuries. I spent about a year researching it during my own hamstring tear. I think it's useful.
But eccentric work looks through a narrow window. It treats the hamstring as if it works in isolation between the knee and the hip. That's not reality. The hamstring attaches to the pelvis. The pelvis attaches to the trunk. Arm swing is involved. So is how your foot plants.
Treat the tissue, then find out why it happened
Think about a knee for a second. Someone hits your knee with a bat. You probably damaged ligaments, maybe cartilage. That's local instability. We need to stabilize the knee itself because something is structurally torn or fractured.
Muscles and tendons work the same way. We treat the injured tissue directly with local stabilization.
But why it happened is a different story. For that, we look higher, and sometimes lower. You'll hear people say "kinetic chain" a lot. I don't love the term. To me it just means getting the whole lower body, the other leg, the hips and the torso to work as a unit, because they're connected.
So with this reader, I'd want to know:
- Does his trunk work well?
- Are his movement patterns good?
- Does he do complex lifts in the gym, even at lower weight: squats, deadlifts, hip hinges?
- Is he training rotation?
- Is he doing lateral movement? Squats and deadlifts are forward-and-back motions only.
Healing takes longer than it feels
Six months out, a lot of healing is still happening. Tissue keeps remodeling for up to a year. I've heard sources say two years. Definitely up to six months.
Think of a scab on your arm you keep picking at. Eventually it goes away. But it took weeks or months. And even when it looks done, it's still changing under the surface. That's why people keep putting cocoa butter on stretch marks. They believe it's still changing.
I believe the same about a hamstring injury. Feeling no pain doesn't mean the tissue is finished.
Key takeaways
- Pain-free sprinting doesn't mean your hamstring is ready for kicking, which uses more range, different force and rotation.
- Build rehab around the exact activity you want to return to.
- Warm-up, cool-down and a possibly larger partial tear are all worth checking when a hamstring flares again.
- Eccentric hamstring loading is useful, but it looks at the muscle in isolation.
- Treat the injured tissue locally, then look at the trunk, hips and movement patterns to find why it happened.
- Hamstring tissue keeps remodeling for months, possibly a year or more.
At a glance
- Conditions and injuries
- Hamstring strain
- Recurrent hamstring injury
- Partial hamstring tear
- Anatomy involved
- Hamstring muscles
- Pelvis
- Trunk and hips
- Plant foot and ground contact
- Symptoms described
- Pain returning the day after kicking
- Hamstring pain after months pain-free
- Treatments and exercises
- Sport-specific rehab for sprinting and kicking
- Eccentric hamstring loading
- Trunk and hip stabilization
- Warm-up and cool-down
- Compound, rotational and lateral exercises
Episode Transcript
This transcript was generated automatically (whisper.cpp large-v3-turbo) and may contain errors.
Welcome to the Performance Place Sports Care podcast, where you can learn about sports injury theory, rehab, diagnosis, and how to understand the doctor lingo you didn't understand at your appointment. And now, your host, Dr. Sebastian Gonzales. Hey, it's Dr. Sebastian Gonzales, and thanks for joining me back at the Performance Place Sports Care podcast. I know I've been gone for a while, and I do want to really apologize for that. The reason for my absence, actually, I was kind of getting burnt out on podcasting, and it was probably because I was running out of topics and information, and I feel like I really, really want to address things that you guys want to hear about.
And second thing was that I really wanted to redefine who I'm speaking with, and I know that I personally really, really like podcasting and talking more complex language and using anatomical terms and so on. And I feel like when I'm doing this, I guess it's partially for me and the fact that it's getting my ideas out. But I had a friend contact me just recently regarding one of the YouTube videos I put up on hip issues, and it was actually part of a series. It was a part of a 10-part series, and it was the very end, so it was number 10. And obviously, he had jumped in the very end, and he was saying, you know what, I think it's good information you're putting out, but 90% of the stuff, I have no idea what you're talking about.
And just, he was giving me constructive criticism about, I need to figure out who I'm talking to, as well as if I'm using complex terms, then I need to define them. My argument was, hey man, like I, this is part of a 10-part series, like I already kind of defined that stuff. I mean, how boring would it be if every single time if I was redefining? But I've been reminded multiple times over the past couple months by different patients and people about how I can make language a little bit easier for people. And I guess that's really a challenge for me, because I don't expect for you guys to learn it completely on your own, but it's my job to educate you and translate.
And that's what I want to make this podcast about now, being able to educate you guys about getting better terminology and being able to increase communication between me and my patients or clients, as well as if you're not seeing me and if you're just listening to the podcast, I want you to be able to communicate with your health care providers. Because I remember in school, not a lot of us were good at communicating, and we would obviously communicate with each other, and we used a certain type of terminology and so on. But when we're communicating to the public, which is our main job, we need to simplify it or translate.
So that's what I want this podcast to mainly be about now. I want you guys to, well, I want you guys, number one, to be, you're going to be more of patients or athletes. And I need to make sure that I am realizing who I am talking with, and I'm not talking to my colleagues. If I am talking to my colleagues, perhaps I can make a different podcast, because that's a whole other subset of terminology. So what I'm going to do moving forward is I'm going to start using some of the YouTube comments that I get as some topics. And I know over the past few years, and I actually did hear a story about another doc doing the same thing.
I've been putting a lot of YouTube videos up on, obviously, YouTube. And if you want to find that channel, actually, just put Performance Play Sports Care, and you'll find it. I believe it's probably youtube.com backslash SB6BB. Don't ask me why. I've tried to change it over the years, but it seems like it was more of a hassle than it's worth. So I'm not really, really tech savvy in regards to that. So if you search Performance Play Sports Care, you'll find it. But what I've realized, and this is what this other doctor realized, too, is that there's so many people asking questions on the Internet.
And there's so many people asking questions specifically on our YouTube videos. And it's a lot. And there's a lot of great questions, a lot of bad ones. There's a lot of people just screaming and asking for help. That there's a need. There's a real big need. And this podcast, I think, could be really, really helpful in regards to educating you guys about the way we would theoretically go through cases presented on at least YouTube videos. Or I actually did put a voicemail service on directly on the website. So you don't even need a phone call to call you to speak directly to your computer. So if you go to P2SportsCare.com, that is there to utilize.
And also another way I want to educate is I created a whole different site called PerformancePlaceHB.com. And there's online courses. And I put a course on there, number one, for the patients that actually come see me in person. I want to be able to communicate well with them as well as some of the basic fundamental exercises or rehabs that we give. I want to make sure they have a resource to go back to and relearn them if they have questions. There's another one on specific niches, such as baseball pitchers with rotator cuffs. I'm going to do one for distance runners, probably for core or knee issues.
These are things that I think you guys will benefit a lot from if you're in that realm. Now, back to the YouTube videos. My goal is I'm going to go back and address some of these comments and pick some of the longest comments there are in there. Because I really feel that the long comments, they're the ones that really actually care. The ones that go through and say, help, please, I hurt, I woke up with it. I mean, those are the ones that I really don't look at too much. I mean, I think they're entertaining sometimes. But it's more of just screaming, asking for help rather than, hey, can I have some advice?
And I'm sure that if you've listened to all my other podcasts, you've probably heard me say the disclaimer that I really, really can't help directly to any of these people or to you guys if I haven't seen you in person. This is why a lot of the default comments that I make on there is, hey, that's too bad. Maybe you should, you know, look at this condition, but maybe you should come in too. Because by law, we're not really allowed to comment and give advice or treatment plans if we don't have a good amount of information behind it. So for all we know, someone has, you know, say we're talking about knee pain.
Someone has knee pain. We could think it's an IT band condition or meniscal tear, but realistically, it could be cancer as well. And we wouldn't be doing you any favors by recommending something that is just going to prolong the process. So I'm going to go redo all these YouTube videos verbally because they have a lot of views. One of my largest videos, which is a hip condition one, actually two hip condition ones are the tops currently. They have a lot of views, a lot of likes, a lot of dislikes. Surprisingly, actually, there's, I don't know why there's a lot of dislikes. I would imagine because I'm not really showing exercises or stretches all the time.
I'm educating, but I'm going to go through and redo these things verbally because with so many views being up, I feel like it's a good platform for people to still comment to each other. And if people don't find the information, it's not going to be helpful to them either. So these are great starter videos, but I feel like I've learned a lot since making them. And I think I'm going to use them as a platform just to educate further. So the first one I'm going to start with today is we're going to go with a hamstring stretching one. And this one, at least currently it's titled, Wonder Why My Hamstring Structures Aren't Working.
And there's a comment that we've had come through there, and I'll read it roughly verbatim. I'll try to clean it up so it makes perfect sense. I have had hamstring problems for the last year or so. I had to stop playing football. I went to a physio to sort things out. Things were going well. I started to exercise again, ran, and done sprinting for months. I felt no pain. Then I decided to move on and kick a ball for 20 minutes. And the pain came back the next day. After six months with no pain, working hard to do everything right, after 20 minutes of kicking a ball, it's back. Very down about it.
So the first thing I hear with this is that it's frustrating. And I can honestly say that, I mean, I've had hamstring issues personally, and I've really taken researching them to heart because I don't want them again. Because I've had two, and it really, really put me down for a while. And right when one improved, the other one, or when it improved and I totally forgot about it, the other one became problematic. Now, I want to make sure that this person realizes that they did sprinting. They did a certain activity, but they didn't do another. And the way I would probably comment on this, or I'm going to comment on this, is that I think rehab should be done so we have the goals in mind of the athlete.
And if this person's goal was sprinting, we should have them within a controlled setting, doing motions similar to sprinting while keeping the hamstring, trunk, hips, and contact with the ground all in mind. If they're looking to kick, there is a possibility, there's a larger range of motion with that, a different type of force on the muscle, and there's a possibility that we need to rehab that as well, and in just a little bit of a different way. We need to address his warm-ups as well. Perhaps he didn't warm up well. Maybe he went out and started kicking a ball with his friends for 20 minutes and didn't warm up at all.
Maybe he didn't cool down. Maybe there's a large tear in there, and we didn't know about it, and it's completely partially torn. And it just takes a longer healing process, but it was ready for sprinting but not kicking. So, again, going back to the theory on this, usually with hamstrings, there is a kind of thought process now is that a lot of it resides within the trunk and the hips in regards to trunk stabilization. Are they doing, is the trunk or the hips, are they doing their, are they doing their job so the hamstrings don't have to work excessively, at least in regards to kicking and running?
There's been a lot of research over the years which shows that eccentric loading is helpful to hamstring injuries, which I've done a lot of research on, and, I mean, I spent even a year, like, researching eccentric loading of hamstrings and other muscles and tendons because it was really important to me during the time where I had the hamstring tear. And there's a lot of great research with it, and I think they're useful, but when we're, with that, we're thinking in a very narrow window, and we're looking at mainly the hamstring and in the theory that it works in isolation between the knee and the hip.
But that's not the reality of it. The hamstring is attached to the pelvis. The pelvis attaches to the trunk. There's also arm swing that should be involved, and planning with the foot, depending upon which hamstring you're injured, the foot contact could be a big issue because when you're kicking, say it's the leg that's on the ground, there is, it spins and swivels because kicking is a slightly rotational activity. So perhaps there's a rotational aspect in this. But thinking with eccentric exercise, it kind of treats the, or we treat the body as a single region. And usually the way I consider this, let's just talk about knees for a second, is say someone came up and took a, you know, a bat and hit your knee.
That would be an example of local or very specific instability, probably, because you probably, you know, damaged some ligaments and so on, maybe a cartilage. And for that reason, we need to locally stabilize the knee because it has a structural issue. And something might be torn, something might be fractured or so on. And the hamstring operates the same way or muscles and tendons operate the same way. We have to treat them, I believe, directly with that local stabilization and addressing the tissue at hand directly. But the reason why it happened is a whole different story. And I think for that, we have to extrapolate that there are issues higher or even possibly lower.
And I know that if you've done some research on lower body conditions, you'll hear a lot about the kinetics chain, the kinetics chain and blah, blah, blah. And personally, I don't love the term because to me, it doesn't mean a ton. It just means that let's make the whole lower body and other leg and hip and torso all work as a unit because they are intricately connected. So that's what I think about when I see this comment here. I think about does his trunk work well? Are his movement patterns good? Does he typically do complex movements in the gym, at least with lower weight, squatting, deadlifting, or hip hinging?
Is he working in rotation? Is he doing lateral movement exercises because squatting and deadlifting are sagittal or forward-backward planes motions? So there's a lot of things that we can assess on this, but for the most part, it sounds like too that six months after, there's still a lot of healing that is happening, at least according to underlying physiology research. Tissue continues to change for upwards to a year. I've heard sources saying two years, but definitely up to six months. There's remodeling that's happening. And I guess think of it like a scar that's on your arm and you keep picking at it and pick, pick, pick, pick, pick.
And all of a sudden, like, finally it goes away. But how long did it take? Gosh, like, could have taken, you know, weeks and months on end. And at least visually, but microscopically, there's still changes happening. And that's why probably people put things like cocoa butter and whatnot on stretch marks because they're looking for it to improve over time because they still believe that it's changing. And I believe the same thing with muscle or hamstring injuries in this case. So I hope this was helpful in regards to hamstring injuries. If you're looking to, again, drop a comment to me or just say hi, go to the website, p2sportscare.com.
There's that voicemail box right there. And I will have, I will be looking at them. My office staff will be looking at them. And I want to hear, I want to hear what you guys want to hear about. And again, that was a reason why I took a step away. I want to make sure that I was talking about the things that my people, that my listeners want to hear about. Things if you can really do to help me is I want you to subscribe to the iTunes podcast, if you haven't already, and leave a comment. I really want to hear what you have to say on there as well. And for the people who left comments already, I really want to thank you already.
And if you're on YouTube, please hit like, please share, please subscribe to the channel. Those are the only ways that I can tell that I'm doing a good job. I really need feedback just like everybody else because I'm the boss of my work and no one gives me feedback because I give them feedback. So I hope to talk to you guys soon and I will see you later.
