Posted in Podcast
Why glute exercises alone won't protect your knees on the trail
Episode 392
15 Minutes – Aug 17, 2026
Chapters
Questions this episode answers
- Are clamshells and glute bands enough to fix knee pain from running or hiking?
- No. Clamshells, bird dogs and fire hydrants don't build strength except in very deconditioned beginners. Your quads, hamstrings and calves need weighted work too.
- Is it bad to let your knees go over your toes when squatting?
- For most people, no. I only avoid it while it's painful, and then we work it back in, usually within two to three weeks. Stairs, cycling and downhill hiking all require it.
- How slow should I lower during squats and step downs?
- A good general rule is two to four seconds down, roughly matching or doubling your time up. Train some faster reps too, because the trail asks you to control load at different speeds.
- How many reps should I do to build leg strength for hiking?
- We use a rule of 8-ish with a weighted exercise, generally under 10 reps. Once you're up at 15 to 30 reps, you're training more endurance than strength.
- My knee stopped hurting, can I stop my exercises?
- I wouldn't. Pain is the first thing to go and the last thing to come. Symptoms often drop under 50% in about three weeks, but without building a resilient body the pain comes back faster.
Pain relief is not the finish line
Your knee stopped hurting. Great. That doesn't mean it's ready.
A lot of our graduates drop the rest of the plan once the pain fades. I get it. But pain is the first thing to go and the last thing to come. Building real resiliency and strength takes much longer than a couple of sessions.
When the leg isn't prepared for the forces you put on it, it speaks out in pain. We call that unpreparedness. It isn't age. It's physical deconditioning.
Your quads need more than glute work
Many therapy offices, physio, sports chiropractic and personal training alike, lean hard on the idea that your glutes are "off" and glutes are all you need to train. There's some truth there. Weak glutes don't help a knee.
But people with knee pain, especially chronic knee pain, avoid using the knee. Their quads, hamstrings and calves decondition in the process.
Clamshells, bird dogs and fire hydrants do not build strength. Maybe for a true beginner. For strength, we work with a rule of 8-ish: a weighted exercise, generally under 10 reps. Once you're drifting into 15, 20 or 30, you're training endurance more than strength.
Deadlifts and RDLs are great. They are not quad-dominant. The straighter the knee stays, the less the quad does. Don't skip challenging your quads if you want them ready for hikes and runs.
Knees over toes is not the enemy
Should you avoid letting your knees travel past your toes? For the most part, no.
Avoiding it only makes sense when it hurts. If going knees over toes ramps up your pain, we modify the squat or the activity for now. That's an intolerance. Your knee isn't tolerant of it right now.
But we put it back in soon, usually over the next two to three weeks. Sometimes there's a small flare-up. That's okay. I can't think of a single case where someone should never go knees over toes again because they had pain once.
Stairs, cycling and stepping down a big step all require it. With body weight, you can be relaxed about it. With load, be stricter. Form matters mainly when there's pain or performance involved, like heavy weight or high speed.
On a descent, landing on your heels keeps your knees back, but you'll slip more. Landing more toward the midfoot gives you more ground contact and fewer slips, and fewer hamstring strains. Your knees will go over your toes. That's completely fine. Just train it in your program before you hit big trail days.
Slow the lowering, then train both ways
The lowering phase (the eccentric, or lengthening contraction) gets ignored. People drop fast or hit the floor hard. I agree that's a problem.
I don't think it has to be painfully slow, though. On the trail you control body weight and pack weight at variable speeds. When I get ambitious on a descent, I speed up. So train both. If you're never going slow, add some slow, controlled reps.
- Lower for about two to four seconds.
- Match your down time to your up time. Some people say double it.
- Pause at the bottom, not just at lockout where you do no work.
Single leg or double leg? Both. Split squats, step downs, step ups, goblet or barbell squats, even a leg press or hack squat. Each puts different torques through the hips and spine.
All of those are front-to-back (sagittal plane) work. When my knees get tired on a long downhill, I side step. So add lateral squats, side-to-side hops or field-style lateral drills. Strength training doesn't have to look exactly like your sport. It builds strength for every activity.
And if strength training scares you, call it resistance training. It doesn't have to be super heavy. Beginners, keep it under 20 reps and pump them out.
Under-loading is the biggest mistake
Body weight split squats are not enough for eight-mile descents. Lunges and back squats alone fall short too.
Powerlifting and a lot of CrossFit style lifting keep weight through the heel and midfoot. The heel rarely gets light. A light heel is the knees-over-toes position trail sports demand. Full-foot drills alone don't give you enough of it.
So add more midfoot contact. A heavy forward lean works well. Box step ups and step downs are great because the box trains the position for you, as long as it isn't too low.
Pain management can be simple. Most people get symptoms under 50% within about three weeks. We don't call that a "fix." It will come back, and faster, if you don't build a resilient body. Rest won't build it. Progressive stress over time will.
Key takeaways
- Feeling better is not the same as being ready for the trail.
- Clamshells and bird dogs don't build strength; weighted work around 8 reps does.
- Avoid knees over toes only while it hurts, then reintroduce it within a few weeks.
- Lower with control for two to four seconds, but train variable speeds too.
- Use single leg, double leg and side-to-side work, not just one.
- Load the knee-forward, light-heel position before long descents.
At a glance
- Conditions and injuries
- Chronic knee pain in runners and hikers
- Knee pain on long downhill descents
- Quad, hamstring and calf deconditioning
- Recurring knee flare-ups
- Anatomy involved
- Quadriceps
- Glutes
- Knee joint
- Hamstrings and calves
- Midfoot and heel contact
- Symptoms described
- Knee pain going knees over toes
- Tired knees on long descents
- Pain returning after symptoms settle
- Treatments and exercises
- Weighted quad strength work around 8 reps
- Gradual knees-over-toes reintroduction
- Slow eccentric lowering with pauses
- Single leg, double leg and lateral squats
- Box step ups and step downs
Episode Transcript
This transcript was generated automatically (whisper.cpp large-v3-turbo) and may contain errors.
You're listening to the Restoring Human Movement podcast. Thanks for joining the movement, movement. I'm Sebastian Gonzales, show curator and head clinician at Performance Play Sports Care in Southern California. This show's for active people, those who refuse to let pain and injury get in the way of their life and how they want to live it. Trails and trips, fields and courts, whatever moves you. Each episode features rotating host, expert guest, and real clinical conversations that help you move better and trust your body again. Here we go. But this is a topic that a lot of our graduates from our pain management aspect or our treatment protocols tend to kind of ignore.
Like they focus on, oh, my knee doesn't hurt anymore, so I'm not going to do the other recommendations. And for a lot of the people who have been told that if you can solve your knee pain, quote, within a couple sessions, then you'll be okay. That's not completely correct. A lot of times it takes a much longer time to build up resiliency and strength so that you can actually do the things that you want to do without having re-aggravation and getting frustrated and thinking that you're old, which is all the things that comes out of physical deconditioning or what we call in our industry is unpreparedness.
The knee, the leg is not prepared for the forces or the tasks that you're going to put upon it, and it starts to speak out in pain. So pain's the first thing to go and the last thing to come. So I'm going to focus on some knee exercises today or just some of the points that I think have been controversial, and I'm going to put my spin on it. So quads are oftentimes ignored when the glute training movements take over. I would agree with that. I think that there's, when you go into a therapy office, not just physical therapy, but physiotherapy or sports chiropractic or even personal training, like sometimes you get these thoughts that your glutes are off and that you need to only train glutes.
And there is some truth to that, like the glutes are latent or not helpful or weak or deconditioned, which doesn't help out with knee conditions. But what we do know with people with knee conditions, especially more chronic ones, is that they tend to not use them a lot. They try to avoid using their knees if possible, and their quad, their hamstring, their calf musculature gets deconditioned in the process. So I want to make sure to point out that doing hip-dominant exercises like clamshells and bird dogs and hydrants, they do not produce strength. Maybe for a very, very beginner or a deconditioned person, yes.
I'm not even going to say geriatric person because I have them do much harder things than that, especially if they're physically able. But usually doing a weighted exercise for generally under 10 reps is kind of strength-ish. We have like a rule of 8-ish, which is pretty fair. You can go under 8, you can go over 8, but, you know, don't start venturing into 15, 20, 30. If you can, you still can get some benefit from that. But ideally, if you're going to work with strength parameter, building strength, not just endurance or turning a muscle on, then you need to work within kind of those rep ranges as a general rule.
Now, if you're doing things like deadlifting, great. But is that knee-dominant, quad-dominant? No, it's not. If you're doing things like RDLs, is that quad-dominant? No, it's not. Like, usually the more you have the knee straighter, the less quad-dominant or knee-dominant it will become. Is there benefits? Certainly there is. But I just want to make sure to focus on that you should not be completely ignoring training your quads and putting your quads through quite a bit of a challenge to condition them for your hikes and your runs. Now, the second point is the knees-over-toes concept. Is it dangerous?
Should you avoid it? No, you shouldn't, for the most part. Now, I'll give you just a brief history on this. Not going knees-over-toes is really only correct when there's pain associated to the task. When we assess people via our telehealth sessions or in-persons, we assess to see does it hurt and is it ramping up pain to go knees-over-toes. In that case, we try to modify the squat pattern or the activity so it doesn't do that. But that's called a tolerance. It's an intolerance, if you will. Your knee's not tolerant of it right now. But it should be installed back in very soon. Most of the time, we have people try to put it back in within over the next two to three weeks if we can.
Sometimes there's a little bit of a flare-up when we do it, but that's okay. We're trying to reintegrate it back in under, I can't think of a single circumstance where we wouldn't have anybody ever go knees-over-toes again just because they had pain in the past. I think that's a big mistake. Now, with bodyweight activity, you can go knees-over-toes a little bit more willingly up and down stairs. Cycling, even, are fine. Stepping down a large step. These all require knees-over-toes. If you do it with weight, you have to be a little bit more stringent with your form. As we kind of say, form matters, but it doesn't matter.
Form matters mainly when there's pain or performance involved, like high weight or high speed. But if you're walking down a mountain, you, or running down a mountain, you can see all these different odd steps that you take. That's fine. If you try to contact on your heels versus your, kind of your mid-foot or your toes, you will go less knee-over-toes. I saw some Instagram videos recently on this where they were talking about how to correctly go up and down, or sorry, go down a hill. And they were kind of demonstrating like the purpose of if you go on your heel, you'll slip, which is correct. If you increase the amount of the ground contact that you have, like onto the mid-foot, you'll slip less.
So you'll have less potential hamstring strains or hamstring tears, but you're going to go knees-over-toes and that's completely fine. And you can condition that, but you just have to make sure that you put it into your program before you start exposing it too much on the trail with big hikes or runs. The third talking point is the lowering phase of every quad exercise is the most important part and almost nobody slows it down enough. I would agree and disagree with this. I think there is a lot of value to the lowering phase of an exercise, which is what we call the eccentric or lengthening contraction.
The concentric or the shortening phase, like you're trying to jump up, is important, but a lot of times the downward phase is ignored. I would agree with that portion of it. People just kind of hit the floor hard or lower very fast and they don't really control it. I'm not going to say that really the speed, like it has to be super, super slow. I think you should be able to control your body weight and extra weight. Let's just say if you're hiking or backpacking, you have pack weight. You have to be able to control a certain amount of body weight or pack weight to variable speeds. I know that when I get ambitious on the trail, I just start going faster, you know, getting going down faster.
And so I have to spend less energy doing it slowly. And I think that's what people are doing with the exercises. They're trying to expend less energy because it is a lot of work to slow it down. But you need to have both. There is no 100% right or wrong. Do both. But if you are not doing slow on the way down, consider doing some slow and controlled. A good general rule is doing about like two to four seconds down. If you want to equate how long it takes you to get up should be how long it takes you to get down in the movement. But some people say double. You should be able to pause between. Some lifts have like pause phases in it.
A lot of times people pause in the phase where they don't have to do any work like a lockout phase. But if you pause into the other part, in this case, the lowering, the lower portion of it, then you could challenge yourself in that position too. I'm down with that. All of it's good. Now for a quick pause before we keep going. Hey everybody, it's Sebastian. If what we've been describing in the show so far sounds very familiar and you've been dealing with some ache, pain, or stiffness that keeps coming back no matter what you do and no matter what you try, we're offering a free discovery call today where we brainstorm with you what has been working for you, what hasn't been working, and we also try to unravel what is a critical part of the puzzle that you've actually been missing that's keeping you from full recovery and getting back to full activity.
The link's in the description. It only takes a few minutes to fill out the form. Okay, back to the show. The fourth talking point is single leg quad work transfers to the trail. Better bilateral squats do not expose the knee to asymmetries and cause knee pain on one side. I would not completely agree with this. I think there's value in single and double leg work. I think everybody needs single and double leg work in their resistance training program. A lot of you will get exposed to single leg work when you're on the trail. If you're carrying a pack, then that is going to be a heavier version of a single leg activity.
But if we're going to actually expand this a little bit into more of what we call exposure training, you guys need to do both. Like you need to do two-legged and one-legged with probably split squats, step downs, step ups, bilateral squatting, which could be from a barbell goblet squat, which are different. They're different torques on different parts of the hips and the spine or even like a leg press or a hack press would be fine too. I'm down with all those, but also those are only in sagittal plane movement. Those are sagittal plane strength work. I don't know about some of you guys, but when my knees get tired when I'm going down a hill for a very long time, I kind of do a side step.
So this is controlling your body in a different plane of movement. So you could do things like lateral squats. I'm not talking about a caustic squat. If you guys know what that is, that is still a sagittal plane exercise, but you can do like kind of side-to-side hops, which is more of a power move, I guess, if you're not doing a lot of them, but you can load it up too. They're called lateral squats. Or if you like to do stuff in a field, you can do lateral drills. That works okay too. Generating power and movement into a lateral plane is a good second point in this. But don't be married to just one.
I think probably where this comes from in social media is that people believe that their strength training should be only specific to their activity. Like single leg work looks like running and hiking and backpacking, so do that and it's going to carry over more. That's not necessarily true. Strength training or resistance training is developing strength for all activities. A lot of resistance training or strength training looks very much the same. By the way, I know you're using them interchangeably. Strength training is developing the attribute of strength. Resistance training could be a little bit different, but when we use resistance training, I think it's a better, provide better con, a better idea of what you could be doing.
Strength training scares people sometimes. Other words, they act like it has to be super, super heavy all the time. It doesn't. Like for beginners, let's just start with some basic resistance training. Let's go on something and I don't care how many reps you do as long as it's under 20. Pump them out. Just feel good about life, right? The fifth talking point is under load the biggest mistake. Body weight split squats are not enough for someone to be doing eight mile descents. Now, I think, this is, by the way, I asked AI to do some talking points for me on this one based upon controversial topics on social media.
I would agree with this actually. so the reason why I agree that doing split squats in this case also lunges, step back or forward walking lunges or even squat, I would say like back squatting is not really enough is because for a lot of people who are going to marry this into going into human locomotion, so forward, backwards, side to side, they need to go a little bit more dominant onto the mid part of the foot as well. If you look at a lot of heavy, heavy resistance training or like your strength sports like your power lifting and a lot of times your cross fits, they, they really have more heel and mid foot contact points.
The heel doesn't really have any lightness to it on a lot of the lifts and so when the heel gets lighter, that is your knee over toe thing and for a lot of people who are just doing full foot contact drills, I don't think there's quite enough knee over toe to really get you what you need for the sport of trail sports. So, I would try to add a little bit more of mid foot contact heel elevated but not elevated kind of doing like a just a lean, a heavy lean forward tends to work well. Again, a box squat or a step down, sorry, box step up or step down works well for this because the object itself kind of trains you unless it's too low or you're married to the idea of knee never going over toe in that case then we have to discuss this but if you guys are having trouble with your training reach out to us we'd love to help you 714-502-4243 we have telehealth sessions and we're licensed in different states to diagnostic testing etc and give you an idea of what's a safe starting point for you.
overall though in the long run if you're trying to be active outdoors you need to have a resilient body that does not come from only pain management it doesn't come from rest so there are a lot of parts that need to be trained and conditioned with certain stressors over time to get what you're actually looking for pain management can be very simple I know a lot of people will tout that there's like you know X amount of days you get rid of your pain you quote we say people say fix we don't say fix here because we know that there's going to be flare-ups along the way but pain management wise yeah a lot of times you can get symptoms down to a manageable amount like under 50% usually within about three weeks period of time it's pretty reasonable for most people but we don't mislead anybody and tell them that that is a solution it is not at all it will come back and it'll come back faster if you don't actually make a resilient body if anything in today's episode resonated with you visit the link in your podcast player there you'll find any free resource that we mentioned in the show any guest links and a link for a free discovery call with us we're licensed to work with our outdoor active people via telehealth across many states in the U.S.
at this point in fact we cover almost half of the population in the U.S. and we add more states every year thanks for listening subscribe to the show and we'll see you in the next one
